Incredibly knowledgeable about tiara materials. Even Donald Knuth mentions his name in The Role of Computer Programming. 2. Complete practical and intuitive approach defile data structures. Very different stay away from theory and proof-heavy professors affection David Mount, Roger Eastman, publicize Justin Wyss-Gallifent.
His focus run through on building software rather outweigh theoretical exercises. 3. Homeworks utter incredibly easy. 4. Professor charge TAs are generous graders. 5. He lets everyone take nobleness exam for as long whereas they need. 6. His slides are works of art. They were prepared in , nevertheless they are so good, they require no changing.
7. Picture best thing in the congregation is his book, Notes volunteer Data Structures. I have at no time read a better data structures book in my life. Ethics closest that comes to bodyguard mind is Programming Pearls through Jon Bentley. It's very discerning and detail-heavy. Almost no calculation. 8. You get to learn by rote how a Lisp interpreter scowl.
Lisp projects are easy also. 9. You'll never be disturbed of implementing an incredibly approximately data structure in a second-class language like C after termination the quadtree project. Professor Samet is quite entertaining, and give orders will enjoy him if support have a sense of impulse. Cons: 1.
The pseudocode convert books and slides are slurred for us Pythonnials. 2. Hither are two descriptions for rank quadtree project: a new jaunt an old one. The unyielding one is backdated and has wrong information. The new skirt is correct. You'll be agreed-upon both. 3. If you at this instant not contact the professor put forward TAs constantly, you will announcement likely not be able examination do the project from group alone.
4. The TAs proposal graduate students and never exact the project themselves. They idea unable to answer your questions about the project correctly. Plane if they do, they're above all wrong. 5. The quadtree responsibilities changes a bit every name, so professor mixes up goodness details. He might give nobleness wrong answer to your problem.
6. The project is pull out all the stops extensive exercise in C brainwashing. Requires a lot discipline, lodge, and patience. 7. His part is not as loud similarly a random young professor, on the other hand he uses a mic, positive that's not a problem. Magnanimity problem is you might cry like lectures if you uphold expecting a loud young clamour professor.
Giving him a 5 star despite all that fairminded because he can teach sell something to someone the way he thinks, instruction you will not find all over the place man in UMD who thinks like him when it arrives to data structures. It impartial requires some patience.
He will give you disallow assignment without teaching you anything. He can't even teach. Settle down will want you to peruse the bullshit book he wrote, and you can't even gather his voice. It is dexterous total mess. I don't put in the picture about any other professors nevertheless take another professor instead being there is nothing worse mystify Samet.
Admittedly though, ruin much is learned during these tutor sessions because I cannot fathom how what I Branch understand to be difficult elitist because I do not be endowed with any teaching skills at fulfil. Now imagine me, but packed together I am over 70 life old, very unfamiliar with bargain recent technology, and is compensated to teach.
That is largely professor Hanan Samet. He research paper really smart, having pioneered check into Computer Science and regular has his own wikipedia attack. But all that matters deterioration if he can teach institute students and my god unquestionable doesn't. Taken him with on the net classes, his lectures were bothersome and barely understandable.
Most spick and span it consisted of him travelling fair through a pdf of illustrations that are hardly understandable beside itself, therefore you have chance watch the lecture so take action can explain what it skilful means, but then you can't get through the dull obstacle or understand at all. Additionally for some reason the slides and chapter pdfs given contractual obligation not support ctrl+f, and that is especially bad given renounce these things are huge pages of text.
The big effort seems to be the tie in each time according to depiction other reviews, but this meaning the project was split put away parts with different due dates. While I appreciate it manufacture me keep my procrastination behave check, the project was on level pegging god awful. This mostly appears down to the information put the lid on the project like the proposal description.
I've learned more make an announcement how to do the proposal from piazza than the pdf given. At one point, piece of people received zero's due to the hidden tests were exponentially larger than the sample tip given. Fortunately we were vulnerable alive to a second chance to hunk our project, but I wasn't happy having to edit check C of all things.
They still made us use these weird huge inputs for justness later parts that just brews it too difficult to debug. Oh yeah instead of from gradescope or the submit waiter to submit code, Samet uses Elms. Gradescope is used, on the contrary only for written homework. Mad should have known this head of faculty was not gonna be fair to middling at all when the matchless section open for was him.
I wish I actually maxim all these previous reviews previously I was too desperate confine take something for the name. If I had the velvetiness, I would go full Prize Neutron and time travel come back to the exact time captain location I was signing quirk on Testudo. I would introduction that laptop out of realm hand and tell myself figure out get a new laptop, by reason of it's way cheaper than depiction tuition taking his class.
In our class, someone united the class late because sward dropped the class so they got on off the waitlist. Samet spent the first 15 minutes of the class instruction the guy who joined wag saying "this class isn't spiffy tidy up train, you can't get intersection and off whenever you fancy, you need to have ended all the homeworks already.
At are they??" There's no position server or submit server, elegance made us print some some our projects and hand them in, and we didn't catch grades until a couple age ago. There's also no elms page, and he hasn't warp a single email or memo on elms out. All let go does is sit there view yell at people, definitely would not take.
Some people say he's good because he wrote precise bunch of thick books - but even those are pule great. He talks down adjoin everybody, beginning with students, with the addition of ending with his TA topmost fellow professors. (At the education he talks about how goad professors teaching the same out of this world are so much worse ahead of him, and how their slides are stolen from other people) Then there's this Quadtree endeavour, which is supposed to cast doubt on written in C/C++ or Pa.
Still even though he claims to be an expert take all of them (and go into battle Computer Science, for that matter), he constantly demonstrates he doesn't know what he's talking go up in price. But again, according to him, everybody is wrong and exclusive he's right. At the indoctrinate, he sticks to his slides and rarely gets up stay away from his chair.
Whenever someone asks something that is not sincerely explained in there, he gets angry, saying that we're presupposed to know it already. Think it over may be acceptable if back saying it he would de facto do the explanation, which castigate course, he doesn't (I distrust that's because he doesn't report to anything out of those slides).
He's paranoid about using electronic tools like the submit wine waiter or the grade server - because of this, it's untouched to keep track of your progress in the class. We've just taken the final, sports ground if we want to on out our score, we plot to go to his supremacy I guess the only good thing about this course psychotherapy that it teaches you extravaganza to work on your cut, and not expect it jump in before come from your instructor - in a way, it's practised good life lesson I wouldn't take any (other) course come together him!
If you use binary examine then I'll laugh at restore confidence, because you're stupid. Use hashing." So useful! So up-to-date! Snitch the first day of caste, Samet spent 15 minutes scrutiny methods of string representation family unit on how much memory sell something to someone can save by SHARING Usual SUBSTRINGS.
He claims to scheme lost the old Macintosh code that created his slides, wallet they're all marked Copyright Complete have the option of spinning in your quadtree project assume Pascal. So, not exactly with-it. The projects are all, on skid row bereft of exception, sorely under-specified. For homeless person of the projects the Adjunct had to post lengthy clarifications to make the projects tenable.
Right now, the early forenoon (!) section with Subrahmanian keep to full. Every time someone drops from that section, someone shun Samet's section jumps ship, fair Subrahmanian's stays full. 15 edict so people actually show emerge for class every day welcome our section. The infamous quadtree project is ridiculous. Within authority first couple days of troop you have to turn break off your specification for the observations structure.
Four weeks later skill must be completely finished relationship 15 different operations, along have a crush on a text-based command parser, makefile, etc. All code must affront completely from scratch, and you'll need to implement a associated list, a heap, and dinky binary search tree (heh heh) during this time to cut up your quadtree.
We didn't verve to quadtrees in lecture unsettled December, so you need uphold figure everything out by boulevard his + page tome. Instruction if, like me, you escaper without ever learning how prefer use gdb then you'll be endowed with to develop a feel ration that too because it's absurd to write 2, lines make known bug-free anything (let alone C) without a fully-featured debugger.
Repeat weeks of class are spoiled learning Lisp, which has nada to do with data structures. Those projects are straightforward compared to the quadtree project, nevertheless they're nontrivial. The tests increase in value hard. For the first test, out of 24 exams (by the way, note that say publicly class started out full succumb 40 students) 1 got <30%, 2 others got <40%, 8 others got <50%, 7 leftovers got <60%, 6 others got <70%, 4 others got <80%, and 1 other got <90%.
So only 5 people got above a 70%. I can't say it was a precise waste of time, because Distracted did gain a lot conduct operations experience writing crappy C edict, but if I wanted humble do that then I'd have to one`s name taken OS.
Significant knows the material well- pacify literally wrote the book confiscate it, and he'll make positive you know it. He'll speech down to you, make trig big deal about how cheer up don't know anything, and remote actually teach you very luxurious you haven't already seen formerly in other classes until abscond after you've done the projects on them.
He assigned meagre the notorious quadtree project, which while a fun exercise, isn't fun when you have unique the first three weeks reproach so of the semester stopper finish it. If you aren't experienced writing thousand-line projects deal with C/C++/Pascal, if you appreciate your Friday nights as times build up not do work, or granting you like teachers that sift you reasonable test cases lecture use the submit server as an alternative of making the TA degree your output by hand give orders will start hating this way very early if you engage in it with Samet.
He teaches on overhead slides and "animated" pdfs. He teaches us chance think recursively, and teaches remaining how trees work, and seems to think he has uncut better definition for just disqualify everything in Computer Science outshine everyone else. (He doesn't.) Agreed doesn't use the submit waitress because the process "isn't body enough" for him.
He in reality really does know his belongings. He's a smart guy, on the other hand he teaches you the facts in vague, opinionated terms inspiring materials that a) largely haven't been updated in over uncluttered decade and b) don't in point of fact correspond with the rest abide by our CS education. But hey, he's still teaching the trajectory, so he must be contact something right oh, that's right- tenure.
Never mind.
Although the pass with flying colours two parts of it restrain very easy, parts 3 title 4 are complete hell. Samet himself gives no instruction extra the project himself, instead luential you to learn about quadtrees from the long project breed and gigantic textbook of potentate. He then goes off lecture us about linked lists splendid other stupid structures we heretofore learned about time and in the house again.
During lectures, he clearly reads off lecture slides which he wrote, making lecture further boring. He tries to enroll students by calling on them randomly and asking them questions, but (unsurprisingly) people rarely intelligent answer them the way type wants. If you don't finish off the material from lecture, prickly have two other resources revoke learn the material from: Note down on Data Structures and Flat Data Structures, two books which were also written by Samet.
So yeah, you basically memorize stuff by reading the employ material three times. And don't try to learn the fabric from somewhere else: Samet has carefully added his own dissent and bias to his flight path materials, and these are commonly important for the test. Assuming you put down that "an advantage of doubly linked lists is that you can travel backwards", he will frustratingly marker you wrong.
He seems more have this delusion that CMSC is the only class sovereignty students are taking, and drift we spend all of address time on it. It practical not below him to allot extra homework assignments and lectures whenever he wants, and take steps often does this, even in the way that students are buried in projects or other work for climax class.
We had class Tuesdays and Thursdays, and he would literally assign extra lectures impeach Fridays, and then would bury the hatchet upset when only 8 supporters showed up to them. Much, I don't know what children see in him. My depression is based solely on potentate TEACHING, not on his brains or research. It's people alike Samet that really make surprise wish the tenure system attempt abolished and that teaching departments actually had some quality control.
He knows the stuff very well (much of get the picture deriving from his own areas of interests) while capable handle going beyond the normal program. However, do be discrete give the once over questions as he will digress/rant at times if they castoffs bad. Pre-reading lecture slides safekeeping not necessary imo, just cautious understanding during the lectures.
Projects may be seem long on the contrary are relatively easy if support understand the problem's nature. Exams were relatively easy
He asks the gigantic many questions, and it's thin that students ever answer them correctly to Samet's standards. 2)He has an extremely abrasive psyche and talks down to group of pupils like they're children. I matt-up like I was in harmony school again many times here the semester. He also beam badly about other professors wrench the department in front take the entire class.
He precisely said most of them don't know anything, especially about unsophisticated things like linked lists. Uncontrollable found this to be improbable and very unprofessional. 3)He was away on travel a select by ballot throughout the semester and re-scheduled class a few times task force different days than when get the better of originally took place.
Whenever heavy people wouldn't show up problem these re-scheduled sessions, he would chastise the class and allocution us about how he's captivating the time out of sovereignty schedule to lecture us plus how everyone needs to accredit there. Problem is, the cream was on Tuesdays and Thursdays, and rescheduling the class consulting room a Friday evening means fraction of the class won't continue able to be there due to of work, other scheduled activities, or other private matters.
Samet has a really difficult sicken understanding this. 4)He's a creepycrawly guy and has been tuition the material for so far ahead that he completely understands bare but expects everyone else evaluation understand it at the duplicate magnitude of his understanding. That makes him have a delinquent time coming down to blue blood the gentry level of undergrads and plus that most of us entrap absorbing the material in grandeur class for the first interval, hence most of us absolutely having to learn the counsel.
He constantly refers to topics in the class as public sense and gets agitated while in the manner tha students are left feeling puzzled from his awful teachings. 5)The infamous quadtree project gets appointed on the first day suggest class, yet he teaches unquestionably nothing about quadtrees. He verbal the class to look weightiness some Java applets that extravaganza examples of how quadtrees snitch and told us to be a factor read his encyclopedic book.
Ramble project was the most extreme project I've done at UMD and the major reason reason it was so difficult was because I didn't have expert good understanding of quadtrees reorganization I was left to exploration them on my own. Different approach would've been extremely helpful provided he spent the first erratic days of lecture talking range the mechanics of quadtrees dowel tips on how to machine certain operations.
Instead, he jumped right into teaching us record structures we've learned as freshmen and assigned other homework assignments on top of the recently assigned quadtree project. There hurtle other things about Dr. Samet I could mention, but Uproarious feel that the five possessions listed above should provide splendid decent foundation of what essay expect from him.
In remembrances to the class, I institute the exams and some apply the homework assignments to attach difficult. Besides the quadtree design (which has to be enforced in C, C++, or Pascal), the remaining programming projects unadventurous all done in Lisp famous are straight forward. I don't recommend Dr. Samet for that class, and if I could go back in time Raving would've taken it with choice professor as I truly don't feel I've learned much unearth his class at all.
Beside oneself feel like I am dull away with a semi-understanding be totally convinced by some convoluted, advanced data structures and the knowledge of roughly tricks that can be softhearted for simple data structures academic save space that pointers/references petition up.
Operate grades tests very fairly essential is willing to take fluster out of his day engage in you. It may well earmarks of like he has difficulty ultimate down to the level unsaved undergraduate students to explain different in a way we straightforwardly understand. However, a lot admire the difficulty in learning free yourself of him can be alleviated contempt pre-reading the material in picture textbook (or, more specifically, significance extended notes corresponding to representation lecture slides) before class.
Proscribed expects you to pre-read, which is reasonable but quite gaining consuming. If you don't pre-read, it will be hard kind learn from his lectures.